2123 Old Mill Rd, Madison, OH 44057

Welcome to your private retreat on nearly an acre and a half, nestled along a quiet cul-de-sac and surrounded by towering oaks, a winding stream, and abundant wildlife—including owls, woodpeckers, mink, foxes, mallards, herons, and even steelhead trout. This classic Cape Cod combines modern updates with timeless charm, offering exceptional space, privacy, and comfort inside and out. Bamboo floors on most of the first level, granite countertops, maple cabinets, stone fireplace in the living room. Inside, the home feels deceptively large, with a bright and inviting main level featuring a ground level bedroom, a large first-floor laundry room with laundry chute, and a beautifully updated kitchen. From the bay window, you’ll enjoy breathtaking views of the wooded backyard that feel like a winter wonderland this time of year. The kitchen includes adjustable pendant lighting, track lighting, under-cabinet lighting, and two architectural features highlighted by custom gallery lights—perfect for ambiance or entertaining. Upstairs, you’ll find three spacious bedrooms, including a large primary suite with a generous walk-in closet and a luxurious en-suite bathroom featuring a curbless rain shower. An additional guest bathroom serves the upper level. The upstairs bedroom floors are rich dark hardwood, complemented by classic wainscoting for a warm, elegant finish. A standout feature of this home is the bonus in-law suite, accessible from a private exterior walk-up as well as from inside the main home. This separate living space includes its own kitchen, bathroom, washer/dryer hookup, main sitting room, and a private bedroom behind double doors. The connecting hallway features dimmable Edison pendants that add style and charm. (Note: This suite is not included in the home’s main square footage—an exceptional value.) The walk-out basement offers even more usable space and has been updated with premium mechanical upgrades, all installed in 2025: • A brand-new high-efficiency HVAC system (furnace in basement; AC condenser under the deck) • A tankless hot-water heater • A new Leviton Wi-Fi–enabled Smart Load Center electrical panel • With this panel, future homeowners can monitor energy usage on a circuit-by-circuit basis and view real-time and historical consumption directly through the manufacturer’s mobile app. • The panel’s “smart circuit breakers” give the ability to remotely turn circuits ON or OFF, receive alerts when a breaker trips (including why), and review energy usage trends — a great tool for energy efficiency and peace-of-mind. • The system is modular and upgradeable, letting you mix “smart” and traditional breakers if desired, without rewiring — ideal for flexibility and future needs. • For tech-savvy or eco-conscious buyers, the panel integrates easily with smart-home devices, EV chargers, and renewable-energy systems like solar or backup generators. New windows throughout the home (2025) provide peace of mind and improved energy efficiency. Outside, the oversized lot is the result of three combined parcels—nearly 1.5 acres in total—offering unmatched privacy and space rarely found in a neighborhood setting. The climate-controlled 2.5-car garage adds functionality, storage, and comfort year-round. This home blends natural beauty, thoughtful updates and modern smart-home features with flexible living spaces into a truly one-of-a-kind property. Ready for its next chapter, it offers everything from serene views to cutting-edge upgrades—an ideal haven for everyday living or multi-generational needs.