For sale

$5,900,000

2 Silver St, Nantucket, MA 02554

5beds

3,640sqft

Est.:

Single Family Residence

Built in 1930

5,327.39 Square Feet Lot

$5,933,700 Zestimate^®

$1,621/sqft

$-- HOA

What's special

Preserving its historic integrityIdeal space for entertainingGenerously proportioned rooms

2 Silver St is a charming and recently renovated 5 bedroom single-family home located in the heart of Nantucket's Old Historic District. Built in 1930, this property combines historic charm with a contemporary fun style. The home underwent significant renovations in 2022, preserving its historic integrity while enhancing its flow and finishes. It features generously proportioned rooms that create an ideal space for entertaining. More designer and end user high quality upgrades were completed over the last two years. The property sits on a 5,328 square foot lot and allows for an additional ground coverage, perfect for adding a garage with a studio or guest cottage. This wonderful gem seamlessly blends timeless charm with modern convenience, offering a truly extraordinary lifestyle.

3 days

664

6

Tour with a local agent

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms

Bedrooms: 5
Bathrooms: 5
Full bathrooms: 4
1/2 bathrooms: 1

Heating

OFHA

Appliances

Included: Stove: New 48" Viking Tuscany 4 Burner Stove with Electric Griddle, Washer: Two- Electrolux Stackable in Primary room; New LG in Lower Level

Features

A, AC, Disp, Ins, Floor 1: Step into elegance as the foyer invites you to the library — a refined retreat perfect for quiet moments or entertaining. The open and comfortable layout seamlessly connects the great room, complete with a wood-burning fireplace, to the formal dining room and the chef-inspired gourmet kitchen, which features a walk-in pantry for added convenience and new updated appliances including an under-counter wine refrigerator and beautiful Tuscany model Viking Stove. A powder room is thoughtfully positioned on this floor. French doors lead to a sprawling, partially-covered veranda overlooking the lush garden, providing a serene space to enjoy the outdoors, whether taking in the sun or sheltered from the rain., Floor 2: The second floor is a private sanctuary, with the primary wing a serene retreat. Here, treetop views, cathedral ceilings, radiant natural light, and a cozy fireplace create an atmosphere of ultimate tranquility and luxury. Down the hall, a well-appointed junior suite awaits, along with two additional guest rooms and a beautifully designed hall bath, offering comfort and sophistication for family or visitors alike.
Flooring: Hardwood & Stone
Basement: The lower level enhances the home’s sense of spaciousness, fun and versatility. Descend to a stylish living area featuring a gas fireplace, wet bar with wine refrigerator, and French doors that open to a secluded covered patio, providing direct access to the outdoor space, dog run and ample parking. This level also includes a full bathroom, additional guest accommodations, and a convenient laundry room, making it a practical yet inviting space for hosting or everyday living.
Has fireplace: No
Fireplace features: Yes - three

Interior area

Total structure area: 3,640
Total interior livable area: 3,640 sqft

Property

Parking

Parking features: Yes, off street

Features

Exterior features: Porch
Has view: Yes
View description: None, Res
Frontage type: None

Lot

Size: 5,327.39 Square Feet
Features: Large Yard W A Dog Run

Details

Parcel number: 166
Zoning: ROH

Construction

Type & style

Home type: SingleFamily
Property subtype: Single Family Residence

Materials

Foundation: Block & Poured

Condition

Year built: 1930
Major remodel year: 2022

Utilities & green energy

Sewer: Town
Water: Town
Utilities for property: Cbl

Community & HOA

Location

Region: Nantucket

Financial & listing details

Price per square foot: $1,621/sqft
Tax assessed value: $4,371,000
Annual tax amount: $14,087
Date on market: 3/17/2026
Listing agreement: E

Estimated market value

$5,933,700

$5.64M - $6.23M

$5,133/mo

Price history

Date	Event	Price
3/17/2026	Listed for sale	$5,900,000+47.5%$1,621/sqft
Source: LINK #91891 Report a problem
11/22/2022	Sold	$4,000,000-6.9%$1,099/sqft
Source: LINK #89071 Report a problem
10/7/2022	Pending sale	$4,295,000$1,180/sqft
Source: LINK #89071 Report a problem
7/25/2022	Price change	$4,295,000-8.5%$1,180/sqft
Source: LINK #89071 Report a problem
6/1/2022	Price change	$4,695,000-5.1%$1,290/sqft
Source: LINK #89071 Report a problem
5/4/2022	Price change	$4,949,000-8.3%$1,360/sqft
Source: LINK #89071 Report a problem
4/18/2022	Listed for sale	$5,395,000$1,482/sqft
Source: LINK #89071 Report a problem
4/8/2022	Listing removed	--
Source: William Raveis Real Estate, Mortgage & Insurance Report a problem
2/20/2022	Listed for sale	$5,395,000+670.7%$1,482/sqft
Source: LINK #89071 Report a problem
3/12/2019	Sold	$700,000$192/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem

Public tax history

Year	Property taxes	Tax assessment
2025	$13,960 +5.7%	$4,256,000 +0.9%
2024	$13,203 +41.5%	$4,218,300 +45.1%
2023	$9,333	$2,907,400 +26.8%
2022	--	$2,292,800 +4.5%
2021	$7,964 -13.6%	$2,194,000 -17.9%
2020	$9,218 +10.9%	$2,671,900 +8%
2019	$8,313 -0.4%	$2,474,000 +4.6%
2018	$8,350 +5.3%	$2,365,400 +1.2%
2017	$7,926 +3.5%	$2,338,200 +2.6%
2016	$7,657 +17.9%	$2,279,000 +26.7%
2015	$6,494 -3.4%	$1,798,900 +0.6%
2014	$6,722 +5.1%	$1,787,800 +2.6%
2013	$6,396 -1.7%	$1,742,700 -3%
2012	$6,504 +2.6%	$1,796,800 +1.5%
2011	$6,337 +4%	$1,770,100 -12.6%
2010	$6,094 +7%	$2,024,600 -1.9%
2009	$5,696 +3.4%	$2,063,700
2008	$5,510 +18.8%	$2,063,700 +10.8%
2007	$4,639 +36.4%	$1,862,900 +55.6%
2006	$3,400 +9.4%	$1,197,300 +27.1%
2005	$3,109 +0.5%	$942,100 -4.6%
2004	$3,092 -5.4%	$987,700 +3.3%
2003	$3,269 +22.9%	$955,800 +41.6%
2001	$2,660	$675,100