19 Bay Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Set on approximately two private acres along the calm waters of West Neck Harbor, this rare waterfront property offers an exceptional opportunity to own one of Shelter Island’s larger estate parcels. With roughly 320 feet of shoreline and a private dock with deep water access, the property is ideal for boating, swimming, and enjoying the peaceful waterfront setting. Located at the widest part of the creek just before it opens into the harbor, the property enjoys expansive water views while still benefiting from the protection of the creek. From the dock, it’s only minutes by boat to West Neck Harbor and a short ride across the water to Sag Harbor and the Hamptons. The grounds offer privacy, mature landscaping, and ample space for outdoor living, whether enjoyed as it is today or reimagined as a larger waterfront compound. Opportunities with this amount of acreage and shoreline on Shelter Island are increasingly rare. A unique combination of privacy, boating access, and estate-scale waterfront makes this property an exceptional offering in one of the East End’s most desirable locations.